2021.10.21 12:22 Pixlr Rent control, why people think it works, why it doesn't ever work and why you should fight tooth and nail against it this November.
The rent control argument should’ve been dead and buried ever since someone made this model of price caps on goods. Alas, as cities around the world have faced affordable housing crises, people have flocked to the simplest solution they could find, and they found rent control and/or rent stabilisation. However, as with many of the simplest solutions to complex problems, it's plain wrong and here's why.
Why people think it works.
"greedy landlords backed by greedy bankers are profiting off increasing rents on people in their area, forcing people to move out and threatening social cohesion and destroying the fabric of our society"
Basically, they want rent to be cheaper in areas with low supply but high demand and their chosen policy to achieve that aim is rent control. What better solution to the housing affordability crisis than stopping landlords from increasing rents?
Why it doesn't work.
Rent controls have long been known to economists as a bad solution to the affordable housing problem. We've had studies ever since the 40s showing how they lead to housing being overconsumed, left to rot, turned into condos, or end up causing shortages which lead to price increases for the unlucky majority not in a rent-controlled home.
We also know that when you have rent-control or stabilization for long enough you'll end up with 2 classes of renters like in Berlin or NYC. Wealthy, longer-term residents who have a 3-bedroom rental in the inner-city for less than 1.5K a month while new students are struggling to get a studio for that same price.
For almost as long as we've known these things, they've been championed by some as the solution to our housing affordability crisis when it obviously isn't.
Not only does rent control fail to solve the affordable housing problem, it also incentivizes people to not move to better job opportunities because they will lose their rent-controlled home and have to pay the real market value for anything that they rent from then onwards.
Empirical studies have shown that rent control reduced the mobility of tenants by 20% in San Francisco, and because labor mobility is closely linked with productivity which is linked with wages, it probably reduced their wages too.
Why you should fight tooth and nail against any attempted implementation of rent control in your city/state/country.
Why? Because rent control is the most effective way to destroy a city other than bombing, that's why! Have a shot at this quiz and see how many you get right.
That's a huge exaggeration, but it really is quite a destructive policy and if you give a damn about the future of your city, you should oppose it.
Rent control creates vested interests and is therefore extremely hard to undo. To understand this point, think of rent control as one giant transfer from the renters of tomorrow to the renters of today. Those renters of tomorrow will pay higher prices so that renters today can enjoy both cheap rent and well-maintained housing. But you've got to remember that "renters of tomorrow" cannot vote and therefore are not represented at all in the discourse around rent control.
Like with many other restrictions, it's mostly self-interested people building up a castle and pulling up the drawbridge behind them.
Rent control is also hard to fight as people are trying to implement it because rent control is a politician's favorite kind of policy. As shortsighted as it is, its benefits to current voters will last for a decent amount of time. Enough time for a politician to have moved on from city-council and as mentioned before, current renters do see a short-term benefit. But when voting on policy and deciding which side you should fight for you should be considering everyone, including people who don't live there at the moment. They deserve housing too. What right do you have to take it away from them?
But hey, my city's rent control policy exempts new housing. How could it ever effect housing supply?
There are a couple ways in which this could happen, and I'll outline 2 of them quickly.
It could decrease the new supply by creating an expectation that rent controls will be expanded, meaning that people who own new buildings will demand an adequate return for bearing that risk leading to an increase in rents for those who aren't in a rent controlled apartment. Rent controls in Berlin did lead to an increase in rents for apartments that weren't even regulated and that's with an exemption for new buildings. Berlin also serves as an example of rent control being expanded afterwards, as does San Francisco.
Also, it serves regulators a problem that's impossible to solve. They must pick between providing new housing and attaining one of the main aspirations of rent-control (keeping long-term residents). When rent control applies to all housing built before a certain date, what's to stop landlords from bulldozing housing built before then and building more homes? There could be clauses stopping landlords from doing that, but that would impede the supply of new homes which is the only long-term solution to affordability pressures. If the government mandates that the landlord must provide housing for long-term residents in their new development, less homes will be built as a result of it lowering the expected RoR on investment. A conundrum for rent-control supporters to think about.
But hey, my city isn't implementing rent controls, they're implementing rent stabilization. Aren't they different?
Rent stabilization in the long-run is just rent-control in another form. Just like a wolf in sheep's clothing, it has all of the drawbacks of rent control which have already been mentioned in this post, just dressed up to look prettier and more acceptable to your average voter.
When you implement rent stabilization, you're really just making the price ceiling slightly higher than it otherwise would be. It's less inefficient than rent control, but the RoR on housing investment is still lower than what it would be without price controls, and therefore the amount of investment (supply of housing) will be lower too. On the margin, you may have more investors than a city with full-blown rent control, but that's only because the price ceiling is higher, leading to a higher expected RoR.
Alternative solutions that actually work, and that you should push for.
Support for rent control is based off the premise that we want more affordable housing so that long-time residents aren't pushed out of their homes as a result of rents going up. A solution to that would be allowing people to build affordable housing in the first place! To put it simply, the less we constrain the supply of affordable housing, the more will be built.
Rents rise because the demand for housing outstrips supply. Same as any other good, except stringent regulations impede new supply from coming onto the market. If those rules are still in place, rent control becomes a glorified city-wide game of musical chairs. It may let you play around with who gets to stay in the city, but it sure as hell doesn't solve the damn problem.
An RBA paper found that:
"Zoning raised detached house prices 73 per cent above marginal costs in Sydney, 69 per cent in Melbourne, 42 per cent in Brisbane and 54 per cent in Perth. Zoning has also raised the price of apartments well above the marginal cost of supply, especially in Sydney."
We could solve it by abolishing zoning, perhaps?
Another policy we could implement if we want to help long-standing residents stay in their neighborhoods is offering partial, short-term subsidies for low income people if they satisfy a number of prerequisites. I've quickly drawn up what it would look like, policymakers have to fill in the variables and patch up the holes.
2021.10.21 12:22 scottgraywolf Remember this gooey mess?
|submitted by scottgraywolf to GenX [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 i3wb 👍🏽
|submitted by i3wb to shitposting [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 crimsongold28002 Spinning in Their Graves
|submitted by crimsongold28002 to polandball [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 Dama_Okulu TÜRK DAMASI | AÇILIŞ TUZAKLARI | SİYAH TAŞLAR İÇİN AÇILIŞ OYUNLAR. № 8/65.
|submitted by Dama_Okulu to TurkishCheckers [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 anonymous-shad0w What Today’s CDC Covid-19 Vaccine Panel Needs To Confront
2021.10.21 12:22 suckmyfatfuckinballs Ex-Bears lineman Olin Kreutz on Aaron Rodgers' 'I own you' taunt: 'I'd like to punch him in his face'
|submitted by suckmyfatfuckinballs to CHIBears [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 AdministrativeJob377 Zig (Zig and Sharko) VS Oggy (Oggy and the Cockroaches)
submitted by AdministrativeJob377 to DeathBattleMatchups [link] [comments]
2021.10.21 12:22 lilspacejoint Wts shako
2021.10.21 12:22 mahdi036 FUDs around the cryptocurrency market are endless. I believe the fact that the market is full of scams is one of the reasons why some people talk badly about crypto.
I think that the cryptocurrency investors know the dangers and the risks of investing in this market. However, if you want to invest now in crypto, you will be hearing a lot of voices telling you that this market is full of scam projects.
I believe the lack of tracking and the absence of governmental authorities are what makes this market special. This is why exchanges need to find a solution to get rid of this issue. For example, ChilliSwap is an exchange that uses artificial intelligence techniques in order to help its traders monitor the coins and notifies them when scam coins are detected.
We need more of this kind of initiatives in order to get rid of the FUDs. I think the big names in the market have a lot to do.
submitted by mahdi036 to CryptoCurrencyTrading [link] [comments]
2021.10.21 12:22 fcpsitsgep What effects do YOU get from CBD?
Interested in vaping cbd although I've used it in the past (prior to having a medical card) and felt little to nothing- even in terms of anxiety reduction and relaxation.
I'm curious what your personal experiences with CBD have been? What do you usually feel, or not feel? Specifically in regards to vaping and/or sublingual, not topical.
submitted by fcpsitsgep to PaMedicalMarijuana [link] [comments]
2021.10.21 12:22 EmmyMay2003 Wow r/memes
|submitted by EmmyMay2003 to MoldyMemes [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 KingPic is it possible to get the vax at home for someone that can't go out?
2021.10.21 12:22 anonymous-shad0w What Are States Doing With New Federal Funding For Medicaid Home-Based Long-Term Care?
2021.10.21 12:22 aaron141 Next gen update already aplied ? Zombie Army 4
I first played it on my ps4 pro, managed to get a ps5 redownloading it, is the ps5 update already part of download or a separate add on ps store?
submitted by aaron141 to playstation [link] [comments]
2021.10.21 12:22 eccome Dystopia in a screenshot
|submitted by eccome to ABoringDystopia [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 Aggressive-Horse-438 I morgen i ugens krise bliver der talt om Annas exit fra DVTO, jeg er spændt på om det bliver en overfladisk gennemgang eller om man rent faktisk får noget at vide
|submitted by Aggressive-Horse-438 to GossipDK [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 Aavir1510 Moth To A Flame HQ Image (3000x3000)
2021.10.21 12:22 Hlavne_neplakej Just 5 more days remain before our upcoming FPS Forgive Me Father enters Early Access, so here are some artworks of the Lovecraftian horrors you'll face on your adventure!
|submitted by Hlavne_neplakej to FPS [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 whataremyhockeys Can I install this "konstruera drawer" on any closet?
Hi, I have a "built-in" closet unit thing (the kind with pegboard holes where you can put shelves/rails at any height). I want drawers and I saw this IKEA "konstruera drawer". My closet is about that width, maybe a little wider (23 5/8" vs 24"). I was wondering if it was possible to install these drawer slides on any kind of closet (perhaps if I'm willing to drill different holes) of roughly the right dimensions?
submitted by whataremyhockeys to HomeImprovement [link] [comments]
2021.10.21 12:22 winter_beard Photos taken one year apart
2021.10.21 12:22 Silver_Sherbert_887 Classic vintage Kayla picture where she shows off her talent of making a taco tongue.
|submitted by Silver_Sherbert_887 to KaylaSimmons_Classics [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 frantzianleader Morbid Adored - Venomous Tusk (Full EP)
|submitted by frantzianleader to Metalomania [link] [comments]|
2021.10.21 12:22 Missie000 D3 ~ PS4/PS5 Community Server ~ Chernarus Map ~ 1P
✔️Active Traders at Devil's Castle🏰
✔️70 Slot Server7️⃣0️⃣
✔️Leader Boards (kill, Longest shot, playtime & currency 📊
🔹Base Building 🏚️🔨
🔹Hunt animals ~ Trade Pelts & 22lrs with the Traders💲💰
🔹Increased Bear & Wolf Territories Across the Map 🐻🐺
🔹Growing Factions with Faction Flag & Armbands 🏴☠️⚔️
🔹Bases only Raidable on War Day 🏚️🪓☠️
🔹PvP in Kill Zones* & War Day only (*designated mili areas, see Discord for info)
🔹Fight to survive the elements, hunt, fish, forage. A server to test your wits!
🔹You-Twitch channel to Share your vids!🎮📽️📺
🔹Awesome Community of Players & Good Laugh on Discord Chat🎮💬💥🍿
☆ ☆ ☆Get 25K Start-up when you meet the Traders ☆ ☆ ☆
*Come Join our Server!! We are a mixed bag of UK, US, EU, Canadian & Aussie players looking for new survivors!*🌐👣
Join our discord: https://discord.gg/fS5rZAedkC
To join, click on the Discord link☝️ and accept the invite. Once you are in the Discord read 📜Server Rules📜
🌠SEARCH D3 in COMMUNITIES🌠
submitted by Missie000 to DayZServers [link] [comments]
2021.10.21 12:22 aaahhhhanna tumblr enhypen jake x reader smau!! ft. txt and blackpink <33
hi everyone!! i’m thinking of making an enhypen jake x reader smau (social media au) on tumblr. it will feature txt and blackpink and will be gn!! let me know if you’re interested! i’ll post a teaser of sorts if you want it!!
submitted by aaahhhhanna to enhypen [link] [comments]